Saturday, December 19, 2009
LA Times Article on DISASTEROUS EFFECT Early Retirement (ERIP) & Additional Firings Will Have On City Services in 2010 (Into 2024) WAY TO GO ANTONIO!
L.A. city retirements threaten a deep and lasting legacyThe exodus of employees approved to ease budget problems will drain the workforce of many experienced people and leave Los Angeles officials hampered in hiring replacements until 2024.
By David Zahniser
Spurred by its biggest economic crisis in a generation, the city of Los Angeles is about to get a crash course in smaller government.
Over the next six months, a budget-induced employee retirement program will shrink its civilian workforce -- a group that excludes the Department of Water and Power -- by at least 9%.
Some policymakers have only begun grasping the magnitude of the exodus of librarians, building inspectors, traffic officers, city planners and other workers, many of them the city's most experienced employees.
When early retirement was approved last summer, Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa and the City Council touted it as the least painful way to avoid layoffs in a brutal budget year.
But the effects of that decision will be felt well beyond 2010 as services are pared back and the city's ability to rehire employees when the economy rebounds is limited.
Once those 2,400 workers retire, officials cannot replace them at a rate greater than 6% a year between now and 2024 without sacrificing the savings that balanced the budget. At such a slow pace, the city could be left with a reduced workforce for much of the next decade, well after Villaraigosa and many council members who endorsed the package have left City Hall.
"As long as I'm in this office, I will not support adding back those positions," said City Administrative Officer Miguel Santana, the top budget official. "Those positions are being taken off the books and should be taken off the books forever, or at least 15 years, so we can meet the objective established by the actuary."
With 350 workers scheduled to leave Jan. 2, Councilman Bill Rosendahl fears that the employees who remain won't receive training needed to keep city departments running. "Can we put [the program] on hold so we can get comfort on each one of these departments?" he asked city budget officials during a council meeting last week.
[See: Deming's 14 Points on "training and retraining you #1 asset"...your employees!]
Tom Coultas, a budget analyst who has applied for early retirement himself, bluntly said no. "The reason we did this is we do not have money for the existing staff," he said. [Looks like the city can't afford to keep city running.]
Union leaders have already begun pressing policymakers to embrace a second wave of early retirements. Meanwhile, Santana said the city's fiscal hole is still so large that he plans to recommend layoffs next month.
"Unfortunately, the early retirement program is not going to be the only reduction in city government," he said.
The looming retirements have been the talk of City Hall in recent weeks, with employees organizing a spate of farewell parties and whispering names of those still weighing their options. The workers who remain, and some who are headed for the door, are anxious about the effect on city services.
Enforcement of a much-debated medical marijuana ordinance will be light because there will not be enough workers available to police illegal dispensaries, Councilwoman Jan Perry said this week. Efforts to update decades-old zoning rules are being dropped, killing a move to give homeowner groups and real estate developers a more reliable set of regulations.
And in the middle of a budget crisis, some of the city's most experienced financial analysts have decided to abruptly end their careers.
"We're losing institutional knowledge," said Amir Sedadi, the No. 2 official at the Department of Transportation, which could lose more than two dozen traffic officers -- and possibly one out of every 10 employees.
Other agencies are being hit harder. City Controller Wendy Greuel, whose audits are designed to safeguard taxpayers' dollars, could see 17% of her employees leave their jobs, according to one city report. The city clerk's office, which runs elections every other year, could see 18% of its workforce quit.
After opening five new libraries in the last five years, the library department is scheduled to lose 15% of its employees, or 122 workers, nearly half of them librarians.
"There simply is no way with that large of a drop in staff that we can continue to provide the current service level," said library spokesman Peter Persic, whose agency has already cut library operations by 3 1/2 hours each Friday because of furloughs. Those unpaid hours off are also designed to reduce salary costs.
Critics of City Hall worry that early retirement will push out frontline workers while sparing management, undermining basic city functions. "Even in the good old days, when there was plenty of revenue, there just weren't good services compared to Burbank, Glendale and other cities," said Richard Close, president of the Sherman Oaks Homeowners Assn.
The planning department, which already has 80% of its staff taking furloughs, could see up to 40 of its workers retire, according to current estimates. Although those departures may not prompt a widespread public outcry, business leaders have been voicing alarm over the city's ability to review real estate proposals.
"Development projects mean jobs. They mean investment in this city," said Carol Schatz of the Central City Assn. "And it's important that they're properly staffed and have the resources to do the job."
Even the LAPD, where the mayor has pushed an expensive initiative to hire 1,000 new officers, could lose as many as 255 civilian employees, including crime analysts and surveillance specialists.
Police officers and firefighters were excluded from early retirement, partly for public safety reasons. The DWP was the only city department to be entirely exempted because all of its workers belong to a different pension system.
After the council's unanimous vote to approve early retirement, members posed for photographs with leaders of the Coalition of L.A. City Unions, which pushed hard for the program on behalf of its 22,000 civilian workers. Supporters described the program as more humane and less time-consuming than layoffs, trimming $47 million in salaries from this year's budget and $137 million from next year's.
To cover its $228-million price tag -- the cost of providing benefits up to five years ahead of schedule, before the money has been collected -- pension officials agreed to pay for the program over 15 years. Although remaining workers will contribute more from their checks to help pay those costs, the city's general fund -- which delivers basic services such as public safety -- will also be tapped between now and 2024.
As it looked to entice workers into leaving, the council pursued a carrot-and-stick approach. Eligible employees were offered cash bonuses and full pensions up to five years ahead of schedule. At the same time, the council increased the cost of retirement benefits for its oldest employees, so that workers with more than 26 years of service would see a drop in their take-home pay if they chose to stay.
The results were swift. On Nov. 2, the first day to apply for early retirement, a line of city workers snaked around City Hall East. Nearly 3,000 have applied, 600 more than the maximum allowed.
Some city officials privately predict that the ceiling for the program will be lifted next spring, once the city's elected officials confront an additional $400-million budget shortfall. Santana said he does not want to recommend that step until he knows how much such a move would save -- and how much public services will be affected by the current round.
Because the program is provided largely on a first-come, first-served basis, "you don't know what you're left with until you're done," he said.
latimes.com
[Remember two years ago when I said this was going to happen? And the city's approach is BRILLIANT! Quantity of people, with NO REGARD as to quality. (We need to get rid of as many people as possible and the person who has worked one year and knows nothing is equal to the senior manager who has run/held the department together for 20 years. LOL! I think Deming created the 14 points ("Methods for Management of Quality & Productivity") based on 14 mistakes being made under L.A. Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa. (HEY ANTONIO...you're a TEXTBOOK case study. Of "FAILURE IN ACTION!" I'm sure your Chief of Staff Jeff Carr has it all handled and under control!]
QUALITY MANAGEMENT CRISIS MANAGEMENT: Zuma Dogg could EASILY sit here all day in my new blogging studio at the beach and blog all the things (out of the 14 points) that L.A. City needs to do in this nightmare ERIP Era of early retirement. But one thing I learned from Deming...he used to charge $50,000 an hour, even though he didn't need the money, at all. It was just to make sure the people ARE REALLY PAYING ATTENTION AND TAKING IT SERIOUSLY. So again, I could blog "methods for management of quality and productivity" that could help the city in this new economic era, for free...but they wouldn't take it seriously enough. So I'd be glad to provide an eight hour seminar for the mayor's office and he can have anyone from the city attend (up to 2000 people), but I now charge $250 an hour for the presentation, since the information has just become more than critical to the city. (6 hour minimum session, because anything less isn't enough). And Antonio or Eric Garcetti has to call me themselves.
HEY, they don't have to...what do I care. I already have the information and knowledge and they are the one's in BIG TROUBLE. Me...I'm looking at waves! Act now...limited time offer at this rare holiday discounted 50% off consulting fee price.
213-785-7272
Tuesday, December 1, 2009
GRAND AVE PROJECT UPDATE: Dubai Funding The Loans...Hope It's "All Good" (Like They Are Saying)
Grand Ave. project not in jeopardy (So they say, for now.)
FYI: Dubai was needed to keep this turkey of a loser project going after PENSION MONEY WAS PULLED OUT OF THIS MEGA-DEBACLE!
The Board of Supervisors on Tuesday asked for a report on whether financial problems in Dubai will affect the $3 billion Grand Avenue project, whose developers have borrowed money from Dubai investors.
State-run investment company Dubai World has sought to delay payments on about half of its $59 billion debt, which unnerved financial markets last week.
One of the companies providing funding for the long-delayed Grand Avenue project in downtown Los Angeles is Istithmar Building FZE, an investment fund controlled by the royal family of Dubai. The fund has already provided $100 million for the project.
"As the world economic markets have responded to Dubai's bankruptcies that are taking place today, the New York developer who is attempting to develop the Grand Avenue project is being funded - I understand - from loans from Dubai," county Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich said.
But Bill Witte, president of The Related Companies of California, which is building the Grand Avenue project, said the problems in Dubai aren't delaying the project.
"Istithmar, the Dubai entity who has been the equity investor in Grand Avenue, has already contributed significant funds to the project," Witte said. "We have no reason
to believe their commitment has changed and frankly we have already spent all the money to get the project ready for construction. It's the market and timing that is holding us back."
With the weakened economy, The Related
Companies has had difficulty obtaining funding to finance construction of the 3.6-million-square-foot development on two city-owned and two county-owned parcels near the Walt Disney Concert Hall. Promoters have said the project would create a vibrant heart of the city with entertainment venues, restaurants, a hotel and a $56 million park between City Hall and the Music Center.The supervisors voted in April to approve a schematic design for the park. The vote came five years after the county and the city's Community Redevelopment Agency created a joint-powers authority to oversee the project - a vision of philanthropist and billionaire Eli Broad and city and county officials. As part of the Grand Avenue project, Related already gave the county $50 million for construction of the park. The money was placed in an escrow account, earned interest and now totals $56 million.
"The park is moving forward," Witte said. "We're doing construction drawings now for the design and every expectation is that construction will start next summer. The money is there. It's not a financing issue at all."
HERE IS ONE OF ZD'S LEGISLATIVE REVIEWS OF THIS PROJECT TO NO WHERE. (Always said this is some of my best comedy writing.)
Saturday, May 2, 2009
LA Daily Blog WEEKEND UPDATE
OVERALL THIS WEEK: The curtain fell down HARD on L.A. City Hall corruption, in my opinion, in a way I haven't seen in the three years I have been following Villaraiogsa and City Council.
First of all, more mainstream media coverage of George, the Numero Uno grocery store mogul, who is facing a FEDERAL life sentence for things that include bribery of a City Hall planning commissioner; and talk of piles of money being handed out in the same weekly stomping ground of Zuma Dogg (City Hall). Although I'm SURE the mayor is not at all thinking about this, at all, and is not at all concerned about this, because although he used to hang out with George the mogul, with Fabian Nunez in Santa Barbara at Santa Ynez Horse Ranch, is no reason one would suspect any ties.
Secondly, the harvest of my effort (being the only guy talking about this all along) sees to be manifesting in real time, as two Villaraigosa-appointed pension commissioners are now being investigated by Security and Exchange Commission (SEC); and another of his pension boys RESIGNED over City Councilmember Jack Weiss' City Attorney Campaign Fundraiser, that he NEVER should have been a part of. And now, a Judge may be making the same finding in court.
Thirdly, all of this has helped generate massive momentum for City Attorney candidate Carmen Trutanich, who has the politcal shady machine against the ropes, this week.
Because, OH YEAH, Villaraigosa's TOP CAMPAIGN contributor (when he was ELECTED mayor in 2005) Richard Meruelo's Muruelo-Maddux has gone bankrupt! They are (one of) the biggest real estate operators Downtown. THAT'S A LOT OF COMMERCIAL PROPERTY!!! As an economist, I am told, "You can only lie, cheat and steal for so long" regarding this story, so look for a HUGE FEDERAL investigation into the downfall. THE GUY WAS VILLARAIOGSA'S TOP CONTRIBUTOR...wonder what we will find and the bottom of THIS one? (Probably a bunch of no-interest loans that will never be paid back, or a bunch of money in CRA projects that may have been approved when Villaraigosa's cousin (now Assemblyman, thanks to his Uncle Antonio's politically thuggish help) John Perez was on the CRA board?!?!
SO IT'S MUCH WORSE THAN IT LOOKS ON VILLARAIOGOSA'S FAKE PAPER BUDGET, and it's going to be much more painful. And we find out that no one did A GOSH DARN THING as Villaraiogsa-appointed, City Council approved pension commissioners LOST $7 BILLION in City pension money, and the city will be forced into bankruptcy in 2013 as up to 56% of every city dollar goes to this pension bailout. (See LACERS.)
So remember, don't support Jack Weiss, who is Villaraigosa's hand picked City Attorney candidate who is being financially backed by the pension commissioners and investment firms who just lost all the money and are now being investigated by SEC.
Overall, not a good week for the mayor and his chances of even THINKING of running for Governor. Here;s how it went down on LA Daily Blog.
Get L.A. Daily Blog delivered by email
Emergency PayPAL Relief Support for the LA Daily Blogger
LA Daily Blog WEEKEND UPDATE (Recent Posts):
-
LA Daily Blog NewsWIRE for Saturday May 2, 2009
Posted: Sat, 02 May 2009 08:23:00 +0000
-
Zuma's LA Daily Blog - "Today's Most Clicked" on BLOG NET NEWS (Statewide) Ranker
Posted: Sat, 02 May 2009 05:03:00 +0000
-
City of Los Angeles...The NEW Graffiti City!
Posted: Sat, 02 May 2009 03:52:00 +0000
-
Happy Cinco De Mayo Week From ZUMA DOGG!
Posted: Sat, 02 May 2009 03:43:00 +0000
-
Wetherly Pension Scandal: LA Daily Blog Reader Weighs In
Posted: Sat, 02 May 2009 03:04:00 +0000
-
FOX-11 News on Pension Probe Scandal
Posted: Sat, 02 May 2009 02:41:00 +0000
-
How Much Would You Pay For LA Daily Blog?
Posted: Fri, 01 May 2009 15:55:00 +0000
-
It's Danny Pang, not Jackie Chan!
Posted: Fri, 01 May 2009 06:09:00 +0000
-
Zuma's LA Daily Blog Update For Friday May 1, 2009
Posted: Fri, 01 May 2009 05:46:00 +0000
-
Zuma Dogg EVENING Twitter Updates
Posted: Fri, 01 May 2009 05:16:00 +0000
-
HUGE!: SEC Investigation Into L.A. City Pension Fund WIDENING as Partner in Firm is ARRESTED!
Posted: Fri, 01 May 2009 04:22:00 +0000
-
BIG Meeting at Meruelo Maddux Tomorrow: Let the RECEIVERSHIP begin!!!
Posted: Fri, 01 May 2009 03:12:00 +0000
-
LA Weekly HOME RUN Issue (City Hall is the ball park, and shadiness is the ball!)
Posted: Thu, 30 Apr 2009 23:28:00 +0000
-
CALANDER CONFLICT: Jack Weiss To Appear at City Attorney Debate During His Own Rick Caruso-Thrown Fundraiser (Where DO you Go?)
Posted: Thu, 30 Apr 2009 18:17:00 +0000
-
Zuma Dogg Morning TWITTER Updates: A lot of blogging this morning!
Posted: Thu, 30 Apr 2009 17:02:00 +0000
-
Partick Range McDonald (LA Weekly) Unravels Villaraigosa's "Safest Since 1950's" Claim
Posted: Thu, 30 Apr 2009 16:17:00 +0000
-
New Los Angeles Billboard Blight Is Low-Tech, NOT Digital
Posted: Thu, 30 Apr 2009 15:28:00 +0000
-
Villaraigosa's Scheme To Sell-off Parking Revenue IS THE SINGLE BIGGEST BONEHEAD MOVE OF HIS TERM! (And BONEHEAD moves are all he has made!)
Posted: Thu, 30 Apr 2009 14:21:00 +0000
-
LA Daily Blog NEWS HEADLINES (4/29/09)
Posted: Thu, 30 Apr 2009 05:07:00 +0000
-
VIDEO: Zuma Dogg Public Comment and BEGGING FOR YOUR DONATION! HELP!
Posted: Thu, 30 Apr 2009 03:50:00 +0000
-
Zuma Dogg TWITTER Updates For (4/28/09)
Posted: Wed, 29 Apr 2009 06:49:00 +0000
-
LA Daily Blog NEWS HEADLINES (4/28/09) - Mayor's Pension Appointee RESIGNS Over Jack Weiss Campaign Scandal
Posted: Wed, 29 Apr 2009 06:39:00 +0000
-
And NOW, a word from our sponsor
Posted: Wed, 29 Apr 2009 05:58:00 +0000
-
Villaraigosa's PENSION APPOINTEE Steps Down Over JACK WEISS CAMPAIGN FUNDRAISER (Too Good To Be True!)
Posted: Wed, 29 Apr 2009 03:55:00 +0000